|
|
| Photo: NEIL DUDDY |
| TURBAN TROUBLE: Karnail Singh was refused entry to the Manurewa Cosmopolitan Club because of his turban. |
A Cosmopolitan Club embroiled in controversy after barring a turban-wearing community leader from its premises has voted not to change its entry rules about headwear.
The Manurewa Cosmopolitan Club's annual general meeting yesterday voted to keep the club's headwear policy - which bans entry to all people with headgear, including those wearing it for religious reasons.
The Herald understands from club members at the meeting that the rules were relaxed to allow headgear that is worn for "health reasons", such as a bandage or a bandanna used by a cancer patient.
Club manager Patricia Rangi did not want to comment yesterday, but said through a spokesman that the club would issue a statement today.
 |
|
| Karnail Singh / Photo - Greg Bowker |
The Manurewa Cosmopolitan Club, in Manukau City, faced strong criticism from the Sikh community last year after it banned leader Karnail Singh from entering to attend a function held in his honour.
The matter was taken to the Human Rights Commission in January, and the parties agreed at mediation that, depending on the outcome of yesterday's meeting, the issue could go back to the commission.
It was the second time in two years that the club had been taken to the commission.
The first time was after it banned a Muslim international student because she was wearing a headscarf.
Despite the club's agreeing at the first mediation to review its head-dress policy, it decided at that time not to make any changes.
Yesterday, the chairman of the Sikh Centre, Verpal Singh, said he had not heard from the club but would be "absolutely disappointed" if it continued to ban guests wearing religious and cultural headgear.
"We will not let the matter rest because the original understanding was that if the AGM couldn't resolve it, then we will go back to Human Rights [Commission] and also consider all the options that are open to us."
Verpal Singh said his group was seeking legal advice for a possible class action against the club.
"The decision to ban religious headwear doesn't just affect the Sikhs.
"It also affects other religious groups and even the wider community, because it would be denying people their right to take certain guests to the club," he said.
A Cosmopolitan Club member, who did not want to be named, said the general feeling of members at yesterday's meeting was that it should not bend its rules for anybody.
"Many felt that once you change the rules to let in people who wear turbans, then the next thing you know is that we will also have to let people wear hoodies and balaclavas into the premises."
Sikhs to take legal action over turban ban - NZPA
The Sikh community is to take legal action against a south Auckland club which won't allow them to wear a turban in the club's bar.
 | |
| Verpal Singh | |
Sikh Council secretary Verpal Singh told NZPA it would apply to the Human Rights Review Tribunal to overturn Manurewa Cosmopolitan Club's decision to maintain its policy forbidding the wearing of headwear in the bar.
"It's the next step in mediation that was started with the Human Rights Commission and as the logical next step we are going to the Human Rights Review Tribunal," he said.
The Sikh community was "disappointed" at the club's decision.
"At issue is not that we want to go there to the club but we don't want to be excluded," he said.
Furthermore, not all Sikhs would be banned from the club - founding member of the Pukekohe Cosmopolitan Club Ganges Singh, who has been visiting the club since 1976, would still be allowed in with his turban.
"That's where the situation is so strange to us," Verpal Singh said.
The Sikh Council issued a statement on Monday outlining the importance of the turban to the Sikh community.
"For practising Sikhs, donning the turban is not a matter of choice - they must don it or feel naked without it. The importance of the turban may be judged from the fact that a Sikh would not greet any unexpected visitor to their home, without the turban... because for the Sikhs that would be akin to greeting someone in one's undergarments," it says.