Journalist Throws Shoe at Indian Official

April 7th, 2009 Source: online.wsj.com

NEW DELHI -- An angry journalist threw a shoe at India's top security official after a confrontational exchange during a press conference over the 1984 anti-Sikh riots that left thousands dead.

The shoe missed Home Minister Palaniappan Chidambaram, who continued taking questions Tuesday as officials escorted the journalist away.

He was later taken into police custody, but it was not immediately clear whether he would face charges, said police spokesman Rajan Bhagat.

Local television channels identified the journalist as Jarnail Singh, a veteran reporter with one of India's largest newspapers, the Hindi daily Dainik Jagran.

Before throwing the shoe, Mr. Singh asked Mr. Chidambaram several questions about the Central Bureau of Investigation's findings last week that cleared a senior Congress party leader, Jagdish Tytler, from any involvement in the bloody riots that left 3,000 dead.

Mr. Chidambaram said the CBI was an independent body and the government played no role in the decision, and called for the public to be patient.

Mr. Singh, dressed in an olive-green shirt and a white turban, then threw his blue and white sneaker at Mr. Chidambaram, narrowly missing his face.

Moments later, Mr. Chidambaram repeatedly asked the reporters in the room to "settle down," and said, "the emotional outburst of one man should not hijack a press conference." Soon after, Mr. Singh told TV news reporters that he regretted throwing the shoe but he felt Mr. Chidambaram was dodging the question.

"I just wanted to ask him how justice will be done, but he was not interested in answering the questions," he told CNN-IBN during a telephone interview from police custody.

"I don't think it was the right way, what I have done, but the issue is right." Mr. Singh didn't say whether he was inspired by Iraqi journalist Muntadhar al-Zeidi, who last month was sentenced to three years in prison for throwing his shoes at former U.S. President George W. Bush in Baghdad.

The 1984 riots, which remain a very controversial issue in India, left more than 3,000 dead, most of whom were Sikhs. The carnage erupted across India after former prime minister Indira Gandhi's Sikh bodyguards shot her to death. Many blame Congress party officials for turning a blind eye or even supporting the rioters in the violence that ensued after their leader was slain.

On Tuesday, hundreds of Sikhs held protests over the CBI's findings in front of the home of Congress chief Sonia Gandhi, the daughter-in-law of Indira Gandhi.

Jagdish Tytler, the center of the controversy, was a lawmaker at the time and remains a divisive figure in Indian politics. He is currently campaigning for re-election to Parliament in elections that begin later this month.

Copyright © 2009 Associated Press 

Comments

Baghdad, Cambridge, Delhi - next is everywhere Romesh Kumar.

Yeah sure my friend. What do you expect someone to do when he is failed by his own country's justice system for 25 years. Chindambram is no less tainted. Merely 48 hrs before this incident he made this comment about Tytler "I am very happy my friend has been exonerated". Really - 25 years on and he still expects patience. When your mothers are widowed and sisters raped and fathers and brothers butchered then come and talk to us about justice Mr. Kumar. Guilt is by association too my friend - when we can hold the Akalis and Manmohan Singh as guilty as Tytler (for no action taken) who the hell is Chindambram to be held not guilty. He is equally involved. To do a crime is criminal but to observe it anbd not do anything about is worse. In fact this guy has shown the guts no other Indian has - maybe thats why you are so critical of him. Revolutions start this way my friend.

kanwarjeet......, This is

kanwarjeet......, This is not a journalist's way of protest or solving the problems. This is hoodlum's way. He has made security agencies to keep a special watch on sikh journalists before they will be allowed to attend and any press conference.

Jarnail

Naam v Jarnail te Kam v Jarnail walla kar taa.... balle shera

Shaabash Jarnail Singh Jee

You have done a commendable sewaa for the Panth!
May Guru Saahab Bless you always with choicest blessings.
Your Shabad PaRRnaa at Shabad Chowki Jatha Lajpat Nagar, Gursikh Sewaa Dal Lajpat Nagar, Guru Ramdas Sewak Jatha Lajpat Nagar, and numerous Nagar Keertans and Prabhaat Ferees in Lajpat Nagar New Delhi in beautiful voice can never be forgotten.

We didn't recognise you at first instant, but when Delhi Gursikhs called to congratulate then we realised what a great sewaadaar you have grown up to be.

May Waheguru Bless you with Sewaa and Simran always.

Shaabash Jarnail Singh Jee and Guru fateh to all Gursikhs of New Delhi and India, upon whom the responsibility lies to ensure that the true feelings of Sikhs and every Justice Loving, Law- Abiding Indian, must be propagated to the Court and Congress president.
and hopefully Congress will learn its lesson once for all to NEVER FIELD TAINTED tytler and sajjan kumar.

I also should remind the whole world that end of the third one in the trio-criminals (H.K.L. Bhagat) was very bad and Painful and he got punished very badly by Waheguru Jee.

Sorry Sukhjinder but...

Sorry Sukhjinder but.... I heard him apologizing myself..... for details you can watch the video on the website www.ibnpolitics.com..... In a an interview with Rajdeep Sahni, heclearly says that I'm APOLOGETIC for my action.... and not ready to accept any rewards for it !!!.........Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki Fateh !!

Well said.....

Well said.....

AxeEffect, Obviously, you

AxeEffect,

Obviously, you didn't like the truth in my message. Otherwise, what was the point of flagging it????

Three strikes and you're out

No one at SikhNet is deleting comments. If at least three different users report a comment as off-topic, abusive or objectionable, it automatically deletes the comment.

"A sound man's heart is not shut within itself but it is always open to other people's hearts. If I am true enough, I feel the heartbeats of others above my own."

Pressing charges wouldn't have been easy PCJ !!

Pressing charges wouldn't have been easy PCJ !! Congress was already under pressure as the very next day there was a state-wide rally in Punjab and Delhi by the sikh bodies to protest against the clean-chit given to Tytler and Sajjan Kumar !!...... Political parties are under immense pressure at this time and are ready to do anything to garner Sikh votes.... Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki Fateh !!

"Durr fite mooh Jarnail Singhaa !!"

"Don't do things that you regret later on "...... Either do them or regret later on !!..... Are we Sikhs so coward that we don't have the courage to support our actions ??..... I respect Jarnail Singh's feelings but don't respect what he did..... P Chidambram is a highly dignified person and did anyone notice the way he told his security guards to take Jarnail away gentlly !!.... Some important things to be discussed are : 1) Jarnail was sitting in the first row could've easily targeted minister's face but why did he deliberately threw the shoe softly so that it doesn't hit the minister ?? 2) Why did he apologize later on for what he did ?? (Is life and job more dear to Guru's Khalsa than his faith??) And if life and job were more dear to him, he should've chosen to behave properly like a journalist.... 3) Was that an outburst out of religious sentiments or it was another CHEAP SHOT to grab attention ?? Sorry Jarnail !! if Tytler still contests for the elections, then we'll have to assume that it was the second option.... 4) Why is he trying to avoid the politicization of this issue when he already know it is very-very important for the community and so much can be done on the basis of this symbolic retaliation ?? (Maybe he's afraid, what sikh you are if u're afraid ??) 5) Why did he say that "Country (India) comes first" when he was pulled out by the security guards ?? (Well Jarnail!! if country comes first, you better respect the officials).... MORAL of the story : Whatever Jarnail did was higly condemnable professionally..... But when he backed-off from accepting it like a MAN, it became condemnable religiously.... If he had chosen to do it, he should've done it like a DARE DEVIL without caring about the consequences.... My message to the CONGRESS : Sikhs are not anti-congress, they're anti-evil !!.... Congress should not be anti-sikh either and cancel Tytler's and Sajjan kumar's ticket like a goooooood party.... Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki Fateh !!

SSA

country comes first means to respect corruption also?? Either do it the right way or dont do it at all......and I will die without doing nothing at all.... Thank god he did something atleast... BTW...He Refused to say sorry for the incident.... But...may be he is too smart and opportuinist....

AKKA

KAAK

Tytler and Sajan Kumar

I support jarnail sing's action. The way he reacted was compleatly justified, as he is a sikh and a part of comunity living in India as a Minority. Shik's are been Supressed always, Politically, Emotionally and in all other forms. There are all the evedence available showing both dogs TYTLER and Sajan Kumar were involved in the anti Sikh roits. The only reason they got away are 1. They both are Hindu Leaders 2. Democracy is a Joke in India 3. Sikhs are still Seen as enemy of Indian Constitutuin. 4. Khalistaan is the only solutuin... Khalistan Zindabad!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! People who dont agree with me, must be Hidus or Sikhs serving hindu leaders. If you are a true sikh then Support Jarnail Singh Who is a true sikh and a Brave Worrior Of Guru Gobind Singh

Hello

I support What Jarnail Did but I dont support the Idea of Khalistan. What would change if we get khalistan???? Badal and ppl like him woukld have change of heart because now they live in Khalistan???? No one would be corrupt because its Khalistan??? There would be no dividers among ppl beccause its Khalistan?? Jatts and Ramgharias and Bhapas would not exist any more?? And so on.... If Khalistan is going to be like this..I am all up for it.. Otherwise...whats the difference???????

shoe throwing by a journalist

If today every educated Indian is forced to discuss and debat the 1984 genocide of Sikh,the credit goes to brave journalist Jarnail Singh. His act may sound bit rashbut what he did no sikh leader,intellectual or business man or clegrgy man has been able to do for last 25 years. Jarnail by his act has stirred the conscious of India.Even the congress paty is forced to rethink on the candidature of Tytler and Sajjan Kumar. But Sikhs have their own Tytler-- Delhi Gurudawara Prabhandak Committee president P.S.Sarna.This shameless creature wanted strong action against Jarnail, He was applogising to the home minister who himself had forgiven Jarnail Singh. there was egg on Sarna's face when police let go Jarnail singh after two hours. We so called educated sikhs are incapable of raising our voice against the crimes committed by congress goonson 1984.If some body has raised it--whatever method he may have applied-we should welcome him. Jarnail Jai ho

Its Genocide not riots (State sponsered terrorism)

Its a state sponsered terrorism against the Sikh Community during 1984 . Thousands of innocent lives were lost and mercilessly beaten and fired to death including the womens , children . Every one involved including the top polician , govt police official . Its a Genocide and not riots . Even after 25 years no justice delivered . The Denial of Genocide is repeatation of Genocide . The Delay in justice is Denial of justice .

In one swift attempt...

The Singh journalist did more for the 1984 victims, Sikhs, and all victims of crimes of humanity than Manmohan Singh or any other leader has. Manmohan Singh apologized to Sikhs on behalf of Hindus hiding behind the curtains, and the Hindu politicians got away with genocide. Even their Sikh agents, like KPS Gill, got away clean. FYI, Manmohan Singh's daughter (Yale grad) has done more for Muslim rights than Sikh rights. She should look to her backyard for inspiration instead of targeting George W. Bush.

JOURNALIST THROW SHOE

THE ACT OF MR. SINGH IS CERTAINLY A WRONG ACT. NO ONE IN THE WORLD WILL APPRECIATE THE ACT AND WITH THE COOL MIND EVEN MR. JARNAIL SINGH WILL CONDEMN THE MOMENTARY ACT DONE BY HIM. ON THE OTHER SIDE THE GOVERNMENT AND CONGRESS MUST UNDERSTAND THAT EVEN AFTER 24 YEARS OF THE GENOCIDE THEY ARE NOT IN A POSITION TO PUNISH THE GUILTY AND IN TURN GIVING CLEAN CHIT TO THE PEOPLE LIKE MR. JAGDISH TYTLER, WHICH SHOWS THAT CONGRESS IS INSENSITIVE TO THE ISSUE. ALTHOUGH THE CONGRESS IN GENERAL AND MR. CHIDAMBRAM IN PARTICULAR ARE GENERIOUS ENOUGH TO FORGIVE MR. JARNAIL SINGH BUT THE ACT IS SHORT OF ACT REQUIRED TO PACIFY THE SIKHS. MR. JAGDISH TYTLER AND MR. SAJJAN KUMAR MUST BE WITHDRAWN FROM THE ELECTION INSTANTLY AND IT SHOUD BE ENSURED THAT THEY ARE NEVER GIVEN ANY SOCIAL PLATFORM BY THE CONGRESS.

SSA

Are you really naive enough to think that PC has forgiven Jarnail out of generosity???? Its ELECTION time, do I need say anything more?

A BITTER MEDICINE - A VITAL STIMULUS

At its face, incident may appear indecent but just as a bitter medicine is necessary to cure a disease, it is a vital stimulus to wake the slumber of otherwise sleeping congress. Had this not happened, can we think of congress giving a second thought to the candidature of the two surviving culprits. Attitude is evident from the way Hon'ble Home Minister is trying to avoid the question from S. Jarnail Singh just before the later hurled the shoe. This also is amply clear from the video clip that Singh didn't target for hitting the minister, he intentionally threw it away from the minister, just to register the protest. " Jooton ke bhoot, baaton se..........."

Well Said

Very well said, he did intentionally threw it away from the minister. If he wanted he could have hot him easily.

?

I Don't Understand How Come Sikhs Still Under India Why Our Elder Khalsa Brothers Gave Up On Khalistan I'm Ready To Do Anything For Khalsa Nation

SSA

Why would you like to have Khalistan??? How different it would be from present state if ppl like Badal etc would be part of that?? Is Badal any different from Tytler?? Actually he is, he is worse. Actually lets give it a thought, let imagine there is Khalistan....You know what would be happening then?? PPl would be fighting for JATTISTAAN and RAMGARIASTAAN and etc etc. and thats just tip of the iceberg

Well said... the Singh

Well said... the Singh should be awarded a medal for the shoe throwing!, only wished he pinged him in the head

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.